1. One in Three Canadians Would Accept a Deal With Tariffs
A new Nanos Research poll commissioned by CTV News puts a number on how far Canadian patience with tariffs has thinned. Only 33.3 per cent of Canadians said they would support a trade agreement with the United States that leaves tariffs on Canadian goods in place. The result means roughly two in three Canadians would walk away from a deal that keeps import duties in force. The poll landed as trade talks between Ottawa and Washington restarted, and it gives Prime Minister Mark Carney a clear read on the political room he has to close an agreement.
The survey reached 1,058 Canadian adults between October 31 and November 2 through a dual-frame hybrid telephone and online random survey. Nanos weighted the results by age and gender using the latest census information, and the sample was geographically stratified to represent Canada. The margin of error is plus or minus 3 percentage points, 19 times out of 20. Those methods make the finding a solid snapshot of national opinion at the start of November, not a passing mood caught in a single day of headlines.
The headline number matters because it sets the terms of the debate in Ottawa. A government that signs a deal with tariffs in it must now explain the choice to a public that has said, in plain terms, that it would rather refuse. Carney has already drawn his own line in public, saying Canada will only sign a deal that protects a viable auto sector. The poll suggests the public line runs further: many Canadians want the duties gone, not managed.
2. Support Has Fallen Since August 2025
The same question drew a different answer a year ago. In a similar survey in August 2025, 41 per cent of Canadians said they would accept a deal that included import duties. The new reading of 33.3 per cent is a drop of nearly eight points, and it points to resistance that has grown rather than eased as the trade dispute has dragged on. Canadians have now lived with tariffs, counter-tariffs, and the uncertainty around both for more than a year, and the experience seems to have hardened opinion rather than softened it.
The shift fits a wider change in how Canadians see their options. The Nanos poll also found a growing number of Canadians feeling confident about doing trade with countries other than the United States. International trade lawyer Barry Appleton put it in blunt terms. He said Canadians now feel courted by partners abroad. He listed Europe, the Philippines, and ASEAN states, and he noted that Canada is talking to India for the first time. The sense of being wanted elsewhere may explain why a deal with tariffs attached looks less acceptable than it did a year ago.
Appleton also warned that confidence in new partners cannot change the map. Seven out of every ten dollars Canada exports still go to the United States, so the American market remains the one that decides jobs and investment at home. That fact leaves Ottawa in a tight spot: the public wants a deal without tariffs, while the largest buyer of Canadian goods has made duties a condition of access. The gap between what voters want and what Washington will offer is the central problem of the talks now under way.
3. Trade Talks Restart as Carney Reports Progress
The talks themselves have restarted in the past few weeks after a long stall. United States Ambassador to Canada Pete Hoekstra has expressed confidence that a deal can be reached before the end of the year. Carney addressed the talks on Saturday during a news conference in Manila, where he said he had a substantive conversation with President Donald Trump just before leaving for his current overseas trip. The prime minister said the two sides are making progress and that a bilateral deal is possible. He added that the two sides are not there yet.
The signals from Washington point in the same direction as the poll suggests they might. American officials have made clear that import duties will be part of any deal the Trump administration signs, and trade specialists close to the file say tariffs are now part of the reality. Maryscott Greenwood, a Canada-U.S. relations consultant who heads Ottawa Street Strategy, said it is pretty unlikely the two countries will get back to a world of zero tariffs. Her read of the talks is that the question is no longer whether duties stay, but how much room Canada can win around them.
Greenwood also offered a note of caution against reading the duties as a total loss. Most Canadian goods still enter the United States tariff-free under the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement, known as CUSMA, and Canada's overall effective tariff rate sits at about five per cent. That is worse than zero, she said, but better than the rates faced by much of the rest of the world. Preserving that relatively favourable position could give Canadian exporters an edge over global rivals in the American market, even if the headline rate is not zero.
4. Ottawa Faces Two Tests at Once
Appleton said any agreement reached now would fall short of ideal, but he warned that failing to secure a deal could inflict even greater damage on Canada's economy by prolonging the uncertainty of the past year and a half. He said a deal still has value if it can deliver certainty. He said the lack of certainty and political clarity is what costs Canadians jobs, inbound investment, and expansion at plants across the country. In his view, the cost of no deal is measured in factories that do not expand and orders that do not arrive.
That leaves the federal government with two challenges that must be solved at the same time. The first is to negotiate a deal with the United States that protects the sectors hit hardest by duties, above all autos, and that gives exporters a clear set of rules they can plan around. The second is to convince Canadians to accept the result if the final agreement includes tariffs, when the latest poll shows most of them would reject exactly that outcome. Both tasks are political as much as economic, and neither has an easy answer.
The poll does not settle the argument, but it sets the price of a compromise. A deal that keeps tariffs will need a case that goes beyond the text of the agreement, one that shows Canadians what certainty is worth in jobs, investment, and prices at home. Until Ottawa can make that case, the Nanos numbers will hang over the talks as a warning: the public has drawn a line at tariffs, and crossing it will cost the government support it may not be able to win back.